Best and Cheapest Home Insurance Companies in Indiana for 2026
Find Cheap Home Insurance Quotes in Indiana
Who has the best cheap home insurance in Indiana?
What company has the cheapest home insurance in Indiana?
Allstate has the cheapest home insurance rates in Indiana, no matter how much coverage you need.
Find Cheap Home Insurance Quotes in Indiana
- Allstate's average rates for Indiana home insurance are cheap no matter how much coverage you need for your house. For a house with $350,000 in dwelling coverage, Allstate's average rate is less than half of the state average.
- State Farm is also a consistently cheap option and a great choice if you want to bundle your home and auto insurance.
- If you own a new home, Allstate and Erie have the cheapest rates in Indiana. A policy with $350,000 in dwelling coverage costs an average of $612 per year from Allstate and $738 per year from Erie.
Best cheap IN home insurance by dwelling amount
$200,000
$350,000
$500,000
$1 million
Key takeaways
- Indiana home insurance rates went up by about 4.4% in 2025, a bit less than the average hike of 5.6% nationally.
- State Farm's rates have stayed fairly steady, with basically no increase between 2024 and 2025.
- Auto-Owners had one of the biggest rate increases in Indiana, with rates going up about 12% between 2024 and 2025.
- Shopping around and comparing quotes can help you get the best deal. But remember to look at more than just price. Make sure a company has the coverage you need, and consider service and claims experience, too.
Best home insurance in Indiana for most people: Allstate
Pros & cons
- Cheap rates
- Good coverage options
- Lots of discounts
- Poor claims service
- Not good for bundling
Why is Allstate the best?
Allstate has the cheapest average home insurance rates in Indiana, along with good coverage options and discounts.
How much is Allstate home insurance in Indiana?
Allstate also has helpful add-on coverages, including electronic data recovery, musical instrument coverage, and coverage for your yard and garden, that can help you personalize a policy to your needs.
Allstate's rates are already cheap, and you can take advantage of the company's home insurance discounts to save even more. You might get a cheaper rate if you have a smoke alarm and fire extinguisher in your home, don't have any home claims on your record, have a newly constructed home or are a recent homebuyer.
Potential issues
Allstate has mixed customer satisfaction, and its claims process isn't the best.
J.D. Power ranked Allstate well below average in its 2025 Property Claims Satisfaction Study. Choosing a company with low claims satisfaction could mean it takes longer for your home to be fixed after it's damaged.
Allstate also isn't a good option if you want to bundle your home and auto insurance, because it has expensive car insurance rates in Indiana. If you want to bundle your policies, get quotes from State Farm instead.
Best home insurance in Indiana for bundling: State Farm
Pros & cons
- Cheap rates
- Great bundling discount
- Local agents available
- High level of complaints
- Fewer discounts than competitors
Why is State Farm the best?
State Farm has one of the best bundling discounts available, making it a great choice for bundling home and auto insurance.
State Farm has cheaper-than-average rates for home insurance in Indiana. Its car insurance rates in Indiana are average, but customers can usually get a 27% average discount on their home insurance and an 18% average discount on their car insurance when they bundle with State Farm.
State Farm also has local agents in 167 cities in Indiana. This is ideal if you prefer having a knowledgeable, local agent to help guide your insurance choices.
Potential issues
State Farm's customers aren't as happy with the company's service as they have been in the past.
State Farm gets 23% more complaints about its home insurance policies than an average company its size. This could mean that customers have issues filing claims, making changes or getting their questions answered.
Additionally, State Farm doesn't offer as many ways to save as some other companies, such as Allstate. This might not be a huge problem, considering the company's average rates are still fairly cheap in Indiana. But you should still compare companies to make sure you're getting the best deal.
Compare bundling discounts
You could save an average of about 27% on just your home insurance with State Farm when you bundle it with your auto policy.
Although Allstate has a cheaper monthly rate and a higher average bundling discount, its high car insurance rates in Indiana mean it's not usually the best option for bundling.
Best home insurance in Indiana for customer service: Erie
Pros & cons
- Excellent customer service
- Good claims process
- Local agents available
- Expensive rates
- Can't buy online
Why is Erie the best?
Erie has some of the best home insurance customer service in Indiana.
J.D. Power ranks Erie highly for both overall customer satisfaction and claims satisfaction, which means customers are usually happy with their experiences with Erie. And according to the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC), Erie gets very few complaints about its home insurance policies.
Erie also has local agents in 128 Indiana cities. Its agents aren't quite as widespread as State Farm's agents, but you can probably find a local agent close to you.
And although Erie's rates aren't the lowest in Indiana, you can save by getting a quote before you need your policy to start, having smoke detectors and other protective devices and bundling your auto and home insurance.
Potential issues
Erie's home insurance rates in Indiana are more expensive than average.
You also can't buy a policy online with Erie. You have to work directly with an agent to buy a policy.
Compare customer service
You should consider Erie if you call your insurance company often. Erie has great service, which makes it easier to get your questions answered.
What are the top-rated home insurance companies in Indiana?
USAA and Allstate are the top-rated home insurance companies in Indiana.
Both companies earn high marks from ValuePenguin's insurance experts. USAA also earned better-than-average scores from J.D. Power for customer and claims satisfaction.
USAA has very few complaints about its home insurance, according to the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC). But remember, you can only get USAA if you're a veteran, military member or qualifying family member.
What's the average home insurance cost in Indiana?
Homeowners insurance in Indiana costs an average of $2,639 per year for $350,000 in dwelling coverage.
That's about 10% higher than the national average of $2,395 per year for $350,000 in dwelling coverage.
Average cost of home insurance in Indiana by dwelling amount
It's cheaper to insure a home in Indiana than it is in Illinois and Kentucky. These states may be more likely than Indiana to experience severe weather, which pushes up their monthly costs.
But Indiana's average rates are more expensive than rates in Michigan and Ohio, where $350,000 in home insurance coverage costs $2,246 per year and $2,015 per year, respectively.
Indiana homeowners insurance rates by city
Home insurance in Indianapolis costs an average of $3,020 per year for a policy with $350,000 in dwelling coverage.
Southport, which is just south of Indianapolis, has the most expensive average home insurance rates in Indiana, at $3,119 per year. This might be because central Indiana is known for its strong, gusty winds, which can cause damage to a home's roof and siding.
Shipshewana, a small town near the Michigan border, has the cheapest average home rates in the state at $2,195 per year.
Find Cheap Homeowners Insurance Quotes in Your Area
Cost of IN home insurance by city
What kind of home insurance do I need in Indiana?
Strong winds, heavy rains and cold temperatures are all common causes of damage in Indiana.
Knowing what is likely to damage your home can help you build your insurance policy with the coverage you'll need.
Does home insurance in Indiana cover wind?
Home insurance policies almost always cover damage caused by wind. Indiana can get windy, especially in the spring, when strong thunderstorms and tornadoes form. Rates for home insurance are likely higher in areas where strong winds are more common because damage is more likely.
According to the National Weather Service, Indiana recorded 67 tornadoes and 555 reports of high winds in 2025.
Even though wind damage is covered, it's always best to avoid damage if you can. To lessen the risk of wind damage, you can:
- Remove branches hanging over your house.
- Secure loose items, like patio furniture, before a storm.
- Get your roof inspected regularly.
If you lose power because of high winds, your policy might cover the cost of spoiled food in your fridge and freezer. Some policies include this coverage automatically, and sometimes you have to buy it as an add-on. Check your policy or talk with your agent to see if you have coverage.
Does Indiana home insurance cover snow and ice?
Snow and ice can cause damage to your home in several ways. Some of them are covered, while others usually aren't.
- Frozen and burst pipes: Home insurance typically covers the water damage caused by frozen and burst pipes. Cold temperatures can cause pipes in your home's outside walls to freeze and expand, which can crack the pipes. When the pipes thaw, the water can leak out of the cracks and cause damage.
- Breaking and falling trees: If ice and snow build up on a tree or branch near your home, it could fall and damage your house. Almost all home insurance policies would also cover trees or branches that fell on your home.
- Roof damage caused by weight: Ice and snow are heavy, and as they pile up on your roof, the weight can cause damage. Luckily, almost all types of home insurance cover this damage.
- Ice dams: These happen when the heat of your home melts the bottom layer of snow on your roof. Since the ice and snow near your gutters are still frozen, the melted water gets trapped and can't run off your roof. Instead, it can seep back into your home and cause water damage. Home insurance usually covers the damage to your roof and walls from ice dams.
Snow is common in most parts of the Hoosier state. Because of its location near Lake Michigan, northern Indiana often gets lake-effect snow, which is particularly heavy and wet. This type of snow can cause more damage to your roof as it piles up.
However, your insurance company might not pay a claim if the damage is caused by a lack of maintenance. For example, if you had a pipe freeze and burst last year but didn't fix it correctly, it could burst again. Home insurance probably wouldn't pay if the same pipe caused more damage.
Does Indiana home insurance cover flooding?
Basic home insurance does not cover flood damage. To have insurance coverage for flood damage, you have to buy a flood insurance policy.
Many parts of Indiana are prone to flooding, especially near the state's many lakes and rivers. The National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) has handled 500 flood insurance claims in Indiana since 2020. Those floods caused nearly $24 million in damage.
You can buy flood insurance policies either through the NFIP or through a private insurance company. To get the best flood insurance, compare quotes from the NFIP to a few different private insurance companies.
How to save on home insurance in Indiana
The best way to get cheap home insurance in Indiana is to shop around and compare quotes.
That way, you can see what company has the cheapest rates for your specific home and coverage needs. You can also take some other steps to get a cheap policy.
Are Indiana home insurance rates going up?
Home insurance prices have jumped 45.4% in Indiana over the last five years.
But the rate hikes seem to be slowing down. Prices only went up about 4.4% last year.
How much have home insurance rates in IN gone up between 2021 and 2025?
The jumps in prices are likely because of an increased cost of living. When homes are more expensive to repair, home insurance rates go up to help make sure companies have enough money to pay for claims.
Indiana Farmers Insurance had the largest increase, raising rates by over 90% between 2021 and 2025.
USAA had the smallest increase, but its prices still went up by nearly 26% in the last five years.
Frequently asked questions
How much is homeowners insurance in Indiana?
Home insurance in Indiana costs $2,639 per year for a house with $350,000 in dwelling coverage. Your cost will depend on where you live, how much coverage you need and what company you choose.
How much is home insurance in Indianapolis?
A $350,000 home in Indianapolis costs an average of $3,020 per year to insure. But that's just for the Indianapolis city limits. If you live in Carmel, for example, you'll pay an average of $2,648 per year. And in Fishers, the same house costs $2,757 per year, on average.
What company has the cheapest home insurance in Indiana?
Allstate has the cheapest home insurance in Indiana. A $350,000 house costs $1,026 per year, on average, with Allstate. That's less than half of the state average. Homes that need $500,000 or $1 million in dwelling coverage are also cheapest to insure with Allstate.
Methodology
To find the best home insurance in Indiana, ValuePenguin's experts got home insurance quotes from every residential ZIP code from 12 of the top companies in the state. Rates are for a 45-year-old married man with no home insurance claims on his record. The quotes are for a 49-year-old home with 2,011 square feet of living space, which is based on the average home in Indiana. New home data is for a home built in 2025.
Our experts used the following coverage limits to get average rates for a variety of home values:
- Dwelling coverage: $200,000, $350,000, $500,000 or $1 million
- Personal liability: $100,000
- Medical payments: $1,000
- Deductible: $1,000
ValuePenguin's analysis used insurance rate data from Quadrant Information Services. These rates were publicly sourced from insurance company filings and should be used for comparative purposes only — your own quotes may be different.
ValuePenguin's home insurance ratings combine complaint numbers from the NAIC, scores from J.D. Power's home insurance customer satisfaction and claims satisfaction surveys and ValuePenguin's own editorial ratings.
Sources:
About the Author
Senior Writer
Cate Deventer is a Senior Writer who specializes in health insurance, Medicare, auto and home insurance. She's been a licensed insurance agent since 2011.
She started her insurance career working as a customer service agent for State Farm. She later moved to an independent agency, where she worked with several insurance companies and hundreds of clients. She quoted policies, filed claims and answered insurance questions. In 2021, she pivoted her career and began writing about insurance for Bankrate. She moved to ValuePenguin in 2023 and began writing about health insurance and Medicare.
Cate has a passion for helping readers choose insurance to fit their needs. She enjoys knowing that her research and knowledge help people choose insurance products that make a positive difference in their lives.
How insurance helped Cate
Cate used her health insurance knowledge to navigate a surgery in 2023. Understanding how her policy worked let her focus on recovery instead of worrying about bills.
Expertise
- Health insurance
- Medicare & Medicaid
- Auto insurance
- Home insurance
- Life insurance
Credentials
- Licensed Life, Accident & Health Insurance Agent
- Licensed Property & Casualty Insurance Agent
Referenced by
- CBS
- NBC
- Wall Street Journal
Education
- BA, Theatre, Purdue University
- BA, English, Indiana University
Editorial Note: The content of this article is based on the author's opinions and recommendations alone. It has not been previewed, commissioned or otherwise endorsed by any of our network partners.
